So this is another crazy theory from a guy on Reddit, according to him the 2009 reboot of Friday the 13th could be a feature-length episode of Insidious. On the surface, both projects star Jared Padalecki, but as the Reddit user pointed out, the in-universe timelines also match up surprisingly well. Taking on Supernatural Sam took on a false identity to hunt down Jason and find the missing girl he pretended was his sister, the theory holds up. There are no parents or any other evidence to confirm their relationship as siblings other than Clay's claims. But as another Reddit user mentions, the main downfall of the theory is how poorly Clay fights Jason. If Clay had been Sam in disguise, not only would he have been more effective in defending himself, but he would also have come up with a solid plan to capture Jason and not just face him haphazardly. But this theory is not without flaws, it remains interesting to consider given the shared schedules. Not to mention, taking down a mysterious being like Jason Voorhees is exactly the kind of project the Winchester brothers are known for talking about. They're no strangers to assuming false identities, and if Sam Winchester read in the newspaper about the unusual circumstances surrounding the missing girl, he probably wouldn't resist driving over to Camp Crystal Lake to check it out. It has nothing to do with Supernatural.
4 Votes in Poll